Comments on: The Five Most Overrated Directors In Film http://cinemoose.com/5-most-overrated-directors/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=5-most-overrated-directors Down and dirty blog about filmmaking, movies and the entertainment industry. Fri, 13 Jan 2012 06:31:45 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1 By: admin http://cinemoose.com/5-most-overrated-directors/comment-page-1/#comment-2386 admin Fri, 13 Jan 2012 06:25:06 +0000 http://cinemoose.com/5-most-overrated-directors/#comment-2386 As a director, David Fincher has a good understanding of pacing and is great at filming a scene in a compelling, visual manner. That said, his story sense is weakness. Give him a good script and he'll do wonders. Give him a bad script and it will look nice, but the movie will not be good. As a director, David Fincher has a good understanding of pacing and is great at filming a scene in a compelling, visual manner. That said, his story sense is weakness. Give him a good script and he’ll do wonders. Give him a bad script and it will look nice, but the movie will not be good.

]]> By: Gb123 http://cinemoose.com/5-most-overrated-directors/comment-page-1/#comment-2350 Gb123 Tue, 27 Dec 2011 10:31:22 +0000 http://cinemoose.com/5-most-overrated-directors/#comment-2350 They censor movie titles? Well, my first post is addressing the recent family film by Scorcese, and the second post the new Rooney Mara movie. They censor movie titles? Well, my first post is addressing the recent family film by Scorcese, and the second post the new Rooney Mara movie.

]]> By: Gb123 http://cinemoose.com/5-most-overrated-directors/comment-page-1/#comment-2349 Gb123 Tue, 27 Dec 2011 10:23:43 +0000 http://cinemoose.com/5-most-overrated-directors/#comment-2349 What do you think about Fincher? I liked "The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo." The only negative was it was too long. They could've cut about 15 min. What do you think about Fincher? I liked “The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo.” The only negative was it was too long. They could’ve cut about 15 min.

]]> By: Gb123 http://cinemoose.com/5-most-overrated-directors/comment-page-1/#comment-2348 Gb123 Tue, 27 Dec 2011 10:18:30 +0000 http://cinemoose.com/5-most-overrated-directors/#comment-2348 Totally agree 100% with Scorcese. I saw Hugo, and that was a big snore. If anyone else had directed it, it would not be getting all this love. I do believe all of these directors have made good movies at some point in their careers, but you cannot act like everything they make is gold. This is why they are overrated. People bring up classic movies to prove their points, but you cannot overlook other movies they've directed that have not been good. Totally agree 100% with Scorcese. I saw Hugo, and that was a big snore. If anyone else had directed it, it would not be getting all this love. I do believe all of these directors have made good movies at some point in their careers, but you cannot act like everything they make is gold. This is why they are overrated. People bring up classic movies to prove their points, but you cannot overlook other movies they’ve directed that have not been good.

]]> By: chris http://cinemoose.com/5-most-overrated-directors/comment-page-1/#comment-2303 chris Sun, 11 Dec 2011 13:45:58 +0000 http://cinemoose.com/5-most-overrated-directors/#comment-2303 wow! you pretty much made these people look like a bunch of hacks, untalented, and dumb filmmakers. i mean really people, i understand if you think they're overrated(even though i feel they're NOT) but you just on things that made you felt like they're overrated and in turn made them look like untalented hacks. you made filmmaking look like basketball dribbling. and if these people are "horrible" then what about the less talented people than these guys. Cinema will look like an art as low as "planking". it has always astonished me when people make these kinds of list. THERE IS NO GOOD OR BAD, THERE'S JUST PERSPECTIVE! wow! you pretty much made these people look like a bunch of hacks, untalented, and dumb filmmakers. i mean really people, i understand if you think they’re overrated(even though i feel they’re NOT) but you just on things that made you felt like they’re overrated and in turn made them look like untalented hacks.

you made filmmaking look like basketball dribbling. and if these people are “horrible” then what about the less talented people than these guys. Cinema will look like an art as low as “planking”.

it has always astonished me when people make these kinds of list. THERE IS NO GOOD OR BAD, THERE’S JUST PERSPECTIVE!

]]> By: Jonny http://cinemoose.com/5-most-overrated-directors/comment-page-1/#comment-2052 Jonny Thu, 13 Oct 2011 07:48:00 +0000 http://cinemoose.com/5-most-overrated-directors/#comment-2052 I don't know about the others but QUENTIN TARANTINO pretty much nailed it right there. :lol: I don’t know about the others but QUENTIN TARANTINO pretty much nailed it right there. :lol:

]]> By: d http://cinemoose.com/5-most-overrated-directors/comment-page-1/#comment-1968 d Mon, 12 Sep 2011 18:09:31 +0000 http://cinemoose.com/5-most-overrated-directors/#comment-1968 You forgot M Night Shalmalon or however you spell his name. A one act director if there ever was one. All prologue no story. But as far as the rest goes Hollywood isn't doing anything new the stuidios and directors are just regurgitating old stories because it is cheaper than paying writers. The next grand myth will come from a writer not a director or producer. Speilburg and all those like him have never created anything. They just repackage other peoples ideas because creation true creation not immulation which passes for creation these days is done by one individual nota commity which is how films are made. You forgot M Night Shalmalon or however you spell his name. A one act director if there ever was one. All prologue no story. But as far as the rest goes Hollywood isn’t doing anything new the stuidios and directors are just regurgitating old stories because it is cheaper than paying writers. The next grand myth will come from a writer not a director or producer. Speilburg and all those like him have never created anything. They just repackage other peoples ideas because creation true creation not immulation which passes for creation these days is done by one individual nota commity which is how films are made.

]]> By: Camclint http://cinemoose.com/5-most-overrated-directors/comment-page-1/#comment-1954 Camclint Fri, 09 Sep 2011 05:53:52 +0000 http://cinemoose.com/5-most-overrated-directors/#comment-1954 Hey dumbassess holes, get a clue ... Christopher Nolan overatted!!! Go fuck your dog Hey dumbassess holes, get a clue … Christopher Nolan overatted!!! Go fuck your dog

]]> By: Nikhil Kuchi http://cinemoose.com/5-most-overrated-directors/comment-page-1/#comment-1933 Nikhil Kuchi Fri, 02 Sep 2011 12:49:47 +0000 http://cinemoose.com/5-most-overrated-directors/#comment-1933 What is this, a list of best directors of all time? If so, then well done ;-) What is this, a list of best directors of all time? If so, then well done ;-)

]]> By: Handsome Pete http://cinemoose.com/5-most-overrated-directors/comment-page-1/#comment-1927 Handsome Pete Mon, 29 Aug 2011 05:18:27 +0000 http://cinemoose.com/5-most-overrated-directors/#comment-1927 I don't know what Spielberg is doing on this list. Sure he's got misfires, but he made Jurassic Park, ET, and Jaws. So maybe he isn't exactly in the same league as Kubrick or Kurosawa, but he's not exactly out of the ballpark either. I would place him somewhere in the vicinity of Ingmar Bergman and Mel Brooks. On the plus side, that Tarantino movie recipe was oddly plausible, I'm even kind of curious to see if it would work. I don’t know what Spielberg is doing on this list. Sure he’s got misfires, but he made Jurassic Park, ET, and Jaws. So maybe he isn’t exactly in the same league as Kubrick or Kurosawa, but he’s not exactly out of the ballpark either. I would place him somewhere in the vicinity of Ingmar Bergman and Mel Brooks.
On the plus side, that Tarantino movie recipe was oddly plausible, I’m even kind of curious to see if it would work.

]]>